Felony vs. Misdemeanor: Understanding the Differences in Montana Criminal Law

Why Understanding Felonies and Misdemeanors is Critical

In the state of Montana, criminal charges fall into two main categories: felonies and misdemeanors. Despite the common use of these terms, many people don’t understand the differences between them or the long-term consequences of each. Misdemeanors can be minor, with limited repercussions. Felonies, on the other hand, can come with incredibly high stakes–They could lead to years in prison, significant fines, and a permanent mark on your record that follows you for life.

If you are facing criminal charges in Montana, knowing whether your offense is a felony or misdemeanor is the first step in preparing a defense and planning for what comes next. This guide will break down everything you need to know about the differences between the two, what penalties each carries, and how they can impact your future. It will also cover what legal steps you can take to mitigate the consequences of a conviction.

What is a Misdemeanor in Montana?

A misdemeanor is a criminal offense that is considered less serious than a felony. Misdemeanors often involve crimes that don’t result in significant harm to another person or substantial property damage (though there are exceptions).

Types of Misdemeanors in Montana

Misdemeanors in Montana are categorized based on the severity of the crime. Here are the two main types:

  1. Petty Misdemeanors: These include low-level offenses such as traffic violations, minor theft (stealing items valued under $1,500), vandalism, or public intoxication. In Montana, a petty misdemeanor can carry penalties like fines of up to $500, community service, or a jail sentence of no more than six months in a local jail. Despite being less severe, a petty misdemeanor conviction can still go on your criminal record and may affect your future employment or housing opportunities.

  2. Serious Misdemeanors: More serious offenses, such as DUI (Driving Under the Influence), simple assault, and partner family member assault, fall into this category. The penalties are harsher, including higher fines, probation, and jail time of up to one year. A DUI conviction, for instance, may result in significant fines, mandatory community service, license suspension, and the possibility of jail time. In Montana, a first-time DUI is usually classified as a misdemeanor, but repeat offenses can quickly escalate to felony charges.

felony montana

What is a Felony in Montana?

Felonies are the most serious type of criminal offense and carry much more severe penalties than misdemeanors. Felonies in Montana often involve significant harm to another person or large-scale property damage. Unlike misdemeanors, felonies generally result in long-term incarceration, with sentences ranging from more than one year to life in prison or even the death penalty for particularly egregious crimes.

Types of Felonies in Montana

Felonies generally fall into one of two broad categories: non-violent and violent felonies. The classification of your felony impacts both your sentencing and your chances of parole.

  1. Non-Violent Felonies: These include crimes that don’t involve physical harm to another person. Common examples are fraud, drug possession, embezzlement, and theft (theft of property over $1,500 in value). While these offenses may not involve physical violence, they are still considered serious and can result in long prison sentences. For instance, a conviction for drug trafficking in Montana can lead to a minimum of five years in prison, depending on the amount and type of drug involved. That said, it is Montana’s policy to provide alternatives for nonviolent felons who don’t have serious criminal records.

  2. Violent Felonies: These involve direct harm or the threat of harm to others, such as homicide, assault with a deadly weapon, rape, or robbery. Violent felonies come with some of the harshest penalties in Montana’s criminal justice system. For example, a conviction for deliberate homicide carries a minimum sentence of 10 years and can lead to life imprisonment. Judges have little discretion in these cases, especially if mandatory minimum sentences apply.

Penalties for Misdemeanors in Montana

While misdemeanors are considered less severe than felonies, the penalties can still disrupt a person’s life significantly. Here’s a breakdown of the typical penalties for misdemeanors in Montana:

Jail Time

Most misdemeanor offenses result in jail time of less than one year, served in a county jail rather than a state prison. The length of the sentence depends on the severity of the offense. For example, someone convicted of a DUI might spend up to six months in jail, while a person convicted of petty theft may only spend a few days behind bars. However, any jail time is disruptive and can lead to lost wages, difficulty finding employment post-conviction, and personal hardship.

Fines

Misdemeanor fines in Montana vary depending on the type of crime. Petty misdemeanors can result in fines of up to $500, while serious misdemeanors, like a second DUI, may come with fines exceeding $1,500. Judges may also impose additional penalties, such as requiring the defendant to pay restitution to the victim or reimburse the court for costs related to the prosecution.

Probation and Community Service

In some cases, a judge may sentence a defendant to probation instead of jail time. Probation allows the defendant to remain in the community but requires them to follow specific rules, such as regularly reporting to a probation officer, attending counseling, or participating in community service. Probation typically lasts for several months to a year, depending on the offense, and any violation of probation terms can result in being sent to jail.

Community service is often used as an alternative to jail time. For example, someone convicted of disorderly conduct may be ordered to complete community service as part of their sentence. This provides an opportunity for rehabilitation while giving back to the community.

Penalties for Felonies in Montana

Felonies carry significantly harsher penalties than misdemeanors, including long prison sentences, high fines, and permanent restrictions on civil rights. Here’s a look at the penalties associated with felony convictions in Montana:

Prison Sentences

Most felony convictions come with a prison sentence of more than one year, served in a state prison. The length of the sentence depends on the type of felony and the defendant’s criminal history. For instance, non-violent felonies, such as fraud or drug possession, may carry a sentence of one to five years, while violent felonies, like aggravated assault, can result in 10 to 20 years or more.

For the most severe crimes, such as deliberate homicide, the penalty could be life in prison or even death, depending on the circumstances. In some cases, Montana law requires mandatory minimum sentences, which means the judge must impose a minimum amount of time in prison, regardless of mitigating circumstances.

Fines and Restitution

Felony fines in Montana can range from $5,000 to $50,000 or more, depending on the crime. These fines are typically used in addition to prison time and may also include restitution—a payment made to the victim to compensate for their losses. For instance, someone convicted of theft may be required to pay back the value of the stolen property in addition to serving time in prison.

Loss of Civil Rights

A felony conviction results in loss of certain civil rights, such as the right to vote, own firearms, or hold certain professional licenses. These rights may be restored after a period of time, but the process is lengthy and complicated. For example, felons must apply for a pardon or expungement to regain the right to vote or possess firearms. However, some felonies, such as violent offenses, may permanently disqualify an individual from owning a gun.

The Legal Process for Misdemeanors vs. Felonies

The legal processes for misdemeanors and felonies in Montana differ significantly, particularly in terms of complexity, length, and potential consequences.

Misdemeanor Legal Process

The process for a misdemeanor charge typically involves fewer steps than for a felony. After the defendant is charged, they will appear in court for an arraignment, where they are formally notified of the charges and asked to enter a plea. If the defendant pleads guilty or no contest, the case may proceed directly to sentencing.

If the defendant pleads not guilty, the case will move to pre-trial hearings, during which the defense and prosecution may negotiate a plea deal. Most misdemeanor cases in Montana are resolved before going to trial, often through a plea agreement that reduces the charges or the severity of the penalties.

In cases that do go to trial, the process is usually quick, lasting just a few days. The defendant has the right to a jury trial, though in many misdemeanor cases, the trial is held before a judge alone.

Felony Legal Process

The felony process is much more complex and involves more steps than a misdemeanor. After an initial arraignment, where the defendant is informed of the charges and enters a plea, the case proceeds to a series of pre-trial motions. These motions address various legal issues, such as the admissibility of evidence and witness testimony.

Felony cases in Montana can take months or even years to resolve. If no plea deal is reached, the case will proceed to trial, which can last several weeks depending on the complexity of the case. Felony trials are typically held before a jury, and the stakes are much higher than in misdemeanor trials, given the possibility of long-term imprisonment or even the death penalty.

The Lasting Impact of a Felony or Misdemeanor Conviction

Both felonies and misdemeanors can leave a permanent mark on your criminal record. While misdemeanors are considered less severe, they can still affect your future in significant ways, particularly when it comes to employment and housing.

Employment

Many employers run background checks as part of the hiring process. A felony or misdemeanor conviction can make it harder to find a job, especially if the conviction involves theft, fraud, or violence. Some employers may be willing to overlook a misdemeanor, but a felony conviction often results in automatic disqualification, particularly for jobs in education, healthcare, or law enforcement.

Housing

Landlords frequently run background checks on potential tenants, and a criminal conviction can make it difficult to find housing. While some landlords may overlook misdemeanors, especially if they are several years old, a felony conviction can be a dealbreaker. Convictions for violent crimes, drug offenses, or property damage can make it challenging to secure housing.

Professional Licenses

A criminal conviction can also result in the loss of professional licenses. This is especially true for felonies, but even some misdemeanors, such as DUI, can lead to the suspension or revocation of a driver’s license or a professional certification. Professions that require state licensing, such as nursing, teaching, and law, often have strict rules about criminal convictions, and even a misdemeanor can lead to the loss of a license.

Previous
Previous

How a Criminal Defense Attorney Can Help with DUI Charges in Montana

Next
Next

What to Do If You’re Charged with a Felony in Montana